Fraud Blocker
top of page

Non-Compliance with Parental Responsibilities in Portugal: How to Prove It

Writer: Detective Alexandre Ribeiro
Detective Alexandre Ribeiro
18 hours ago
5 min read

The weekend was yours, but the child «was ill». The following week there was a party. Then the phone stopped being answered. When the arrangements set in the regulation of parental responsibilities are not complied with, the law gives you a specific way to respond: non-compliance proceedings. In this guide we explain how they work, what the court can decide and, above all, how to prove each failure in a way the court can take into account. See also our investigation service in child custody cases.


Quick answer: what is non-compliance with parental responsibilities?

Non-compliance occurs when one of the parents, or the person to whom the child has been entrusted, does not comply with what was agreed or decided: does not hand over the child on contact days, does not pick them up, does not pay maintenance or takes alone decisions that should be joint. The other parent or the Public Prosecutor's Office can ask the court to enforce the arrangements, and the court can order the parent who does not comply to pay a fine of up to 20 units of account and compensation (Article 41 of the General Regime of Civil Guardianship Proceedings).


Non-compliance with parental responsibilities: a child's shoes and bag by the door and a calendar with crossed-out dates

Key points

  • Non-compliance proceedings apply to any part of the agreement or decision: contact, handovers, maintenance, joint decisions.

  • The court can order enforcement, impose a fine of up to 20 UC and set compensation.

  • For contact, the court can order measures so that handovers take place.

  • Failing to hand over the child in a repeated and unjustified way can be the crime of child abduction (subtração de menor).

  • The strength of the request depends on proof of each failure: dates, times, witnesses, records.


How non-compliance proceedings work

The request is filed in court, as a rule in the same proceedings in which the regulation was made, as an annex. The judge usually calls the parents to a conference, where they can reach an agreement, including on a change to the arrangements. If there is no agreement, the case goes on to a decision, and the court can order the steps needed for the arrangements to be complied with (Article 41 of the General Regime of Civil Guardianship Proceedings).


The most common forms of non-compliance

  • Refusing or delaying the handover of the child on contact days.

  • Not picking up the child on the set days, leaving them waiting.

  • Preventing contact by phone or video call provided for in the agreement.

  • Not paying maintenance or extraordinary expenses. See overdue child maintenance.

  • Changing the child's residence or school without the other parent's agreement.

  • Travelling abroad with the child without authorisation. See child abduction.


How to prove non-compliance

A court needs concrete facts. A statement such as «he never lets me see my son» is worth little; a list of dates, with what happened on each one, is worth a lot.


What you should gather yourself

  • A written record of each failure: date, agreed time, what happened, the reason given.

  • Messages and emails about contact, without deleting them.

  • Witnesses present at failed handovers.

  • Proof of payment, or of its absence, in the case of maintenance.


When an investigation is useful

There are situations where your word against the other parent's is not enough: when it is claimed the child was ill and was not, that they were not at home and were, or when the other parent leaves the child with third parties on their days. In those cases we observe and document, in public places and discreetly, what happens on the relevant days and times, and we deliver a written report, with photos and video, that your lawyer can submit in the proceedings. The child is never the target of the investigation.


And if the non-compliance continues?

Repeated non-compliance may justify a change to parental responsibilities, including the child's residence, and, in cases of repeated and unjustified refusal or delay in handovers, a complaint for child abduction (Article 249 of the Penal Code). When there are signs that one parent is trying to push the child away from the other, see also parental alienation.


This article is for information only and does not replace advice from a lawyer. If you are looking for one, see our selection of family lawyers in Portugal.


How we work

Work starts with a free, confidential initial assessment, followed by a fixed quote that includes travel and equipment, with no hidden costs. For field work we usually need 24 hours' notice. At the end we deliver a written report with everything observed, together with photos and video. All investigations are coordinated by private detective Alexandre Ribeiro, a private investigator since 2001 and a member of WAD (no. 1687), APDPE (no. 1326), LIDEPPE (member no. 33) and IKD.


Frequently asked questions about non-compliance with parental responsibilities

What is non-compliance with parental responsibilities?

It is the failure to comply with what was agreed or decided about the child, such as not handing them over on contact days, not paying maintenance or taking alone decisions that should be joint.


What can the court do in case of non-compliance?

It can order the steps needed for enforcement, order the parent who does not comply to pay a fine of up to 20 units of account and set compensation in favour of the child, the applicant or both (Article 41 of the General Regime of Civil Guardianship Proceedings).


The mother won't let the father see the child. What can he do?

If contact arrangements have been set, the father can file non-compliance proceedings. If the refusal is repeated and unjustified, the crime of child abduction may also be at stake, which depends on a complaint.


Where is the non-compliance request filed?

As a rule, in the court where the regulation took place, as an annex to those proceedings. If the agreement was made elsewhere, your lawyer will tell you which court is competent.


How can you prove the other parent does not comply with visits?

With a dated record of each failure, the messages exchanged, witnesses and, when one parent's word against the other's is not enough, an independent observation report.


Can non-compliance lead to a change of custody?

It can. Repeated non-compliance may be one of the circumstances that justify requesting a new regulation of parental responsibilities (Article 42 of the General Regime of Civil Guardianship Proceedings). The decision always depends on the child's interest.


Are the parental responsibilities arrangements not being complied with?

Talking to us is confidential and involves no commitment. We work throughout the country, including Lisbon, Porto and the Algarve. Call or send a WhatsApp message to +351 936 225 975, 24 hours a day, or use our contact page.


Comments


private detectives-portugal
bottom of page