Fraud Blocker
top of page

Actio Pauliana in Portugal: How to Prove the Debtor Transferred Assets to Someone Else

Writer: Detective Alexandre Ribeiro
Detective Alexandre Ribeiro
Nov 9
5 min read

You have won the case, or are about to, and discover that the debtor no longer has anything in their name. The house was given to the children, the car was transferred to their partner and their share in the company was sold to a friend, all a few months after the debt arose. In Portugal, the law has an answer for this: the impugnação pauliana (actio pauliana). In this guide we explain what it is, its requirements, the deadline and, above all, how to gather proof that the assets were transferred to someone else, which is what our asset investigation does.


Quick answer: what is the impugnação pauliana?

The impugnação pauliana is the action that allows a creditor to challenge acts by the debtor that reduce their assets and prevent them from paying the debt, such as gifts, sales or other transfers (articles 610 to 618 of the Civil Code). If the action succeeds, the creditor can enforce against those assets in the hands of whoever received them, to the extent of their interest. It must be brought within 5 years of the date of the act.


Actio pauliana: house keys on a document folder on a notary's desk

Key points

  • The act must reduce the creditor's security and not be of a personal nature.

  • As a rule, the debt must predate the act. If it came later, the act must have been carried out with intent to prevent payment to the future creditor.

  • The act must result in the creditor being unable to recover the debt, or make that harder.

  • For gifts, bad faith does not need to be proved. For sales and other acts for value, the bad faith of both the debtor and the buyer must be proved.

  • The deadline is 5 years from the date of the act, not from when the creditor found out about it.


The requirements of the impugnação pauliana

An act that harms the creditor

An act may be challenged if it reduces the assets securing the debt and is not of a personal nature, provided the debt predates the act or, if it came later, the act was carried out deliberately to prevent the future creditor from being paid. The act must also make it impossible for the creditor to recover the debt in full, or make that harder (article 610 of the Civil Code).


Who has to prove what

The creditor must prove the amount of the debt. It is up to the debtor, or the third party who wants to keep the transaction, to prove that the debtor has seizable assets of equal or greater value (article 611 of the Civil Code). In other words, if the debtor has been left with nothing, it is they who must show they can still pay.


Bad faith, only for acts for value

If the act was free of charge, such as a gift, it can be challenged even if the debtor and the recipient acted in good faith. If it was for value, such as a sale, it can only be challenged if both acted in bad faith. The law defines bad faith as awareness of the harm the act causes the creditor (article 612 of the Civil Code). There is no need to prove an intention to cause harm: it is enough to show that both knew the transaction left the creditor with no way of being paid.


The 5-year deadline

The right to challenge expires 5 years after the date of the act (article 618 of the Civil Code). The period runs from the transaction, not from the day the creditor discovered it. That is why it pays to act quickly.


What happens if the action succeeds

The transaction does not disappear: it remains valid between the debtor and the person who received the assets. But the creditor is entitled to have the assets returned to the extent of their interest, and can enforce against them in the hands of whoever received them and take steps to preserve their security. These effects benefit only the creditor who brought the action (article 616 of the Civil Code).


Where the difficulty lies: proof

The law is clear. What often fails is the proof. To go ahead, your lawyer needs to know:


  • What assets the debtor had before the debt and where they went.

  • Who received them and their relationship with the debtor: children, spouse, partner, business partners, friends.

  • On what dates the transactions took place, to confirm the order in relation to the debt and the 5-year deadline.

  • Whether the debtor still uses the assets, for example if they live in the house they "sold" or drive the car that is in someone else's name. This is a strong sign that the transaction was used to hide them.

  • Whether the debtor has other assets, to rule out the argument that they can still pay.


What we do for you

  • A survey of the debtor's assets and identification of the assets transferred to third parties.

  • Identification of who received the assets and their connection to the debtor.

  • Observation in public places to document who actually uses the house, the car or the business.

  • Written report, with photos and video where there is observation on the ground, for your lawyer to use in the action.


We do not access banking information, which is protected by banking secrecy. This article is for information only and does not replace advice from a lawyer. If the debtor still has assets but there are signs they are about to make them disappear, see also freezing orders (arresto), and for the full debt collection process, debtor won't pay: how to find out if they have assets.


How we handle these cases

We often work alongside lawyers and companies. Work begins with a free, confidential initial assessment, followed by a fixed quote that includes travel and equipment, with no hidden costs. For work on the ground we usually need 24 hours' notice. All investigations are coordinated by detective Alexandre Ribeiro, a private investigator since 2001 and a member of WAD (no. 1687), APDPE (no. 1326), LIDEPPE (member no. 33) and IKD.


Frequently asked questions about the impugnação pauliana

What is the impugnação pauliana?

It is the action that allows a creditor to challenge acts by the debtor, such as gifts or sales, that reduce their assets and prevent them from paying the debt (articles 610 to 618 of the Civil Code).


What is the deadline for the impugnação pauliana?

5 years from the date of the act being challenged (article 618 of the Civil Code). The period runs from the transaction, not from when the creditor discovered it.


Does the debtor's bad faith have to be proved?

For gifts and other acts free of charge, no. For sales and other acts for value, the bad faith of both the debtor and the recipient must be proved, meaning that both were aware of the harm they were causing the creditor (article 612 of the Civil Code).


The debtor gave the house to their children. Can I do anything?

A gift is an act free of charge and can be challenged even without bad faith, provided the other requirements are met. Speak to your lawyer and gather the evidence as soon as possible, because of the 5-year deadline.


Does the impugnação pauliana cancel the transaction?

No. The transaction remains valid between the parties, but the creditor can enforce against the assets in the hands of whoever received them, to the extent of their interest (article 616 of the Civil Code).


What if the debt arose after the sale?

It can still be challenged, but only if the act was carried out with intent to prevent the future creditor from being paid (article 610 of the Civil Code).


How do I prove the assets were transferred to someone else?

You need to identify the assets, who received them, the dates and, often, show that the debtor still uses them. That is the work of our asset investigation.


Need to prove the debtor hid assets?

Talking to us is confidential and involves no commitment. We work throughout the country, including Lisbon, Porto and the Algarve. Call or send a WhatsApp message to +351 936 225 975, 24 hours a day, or use our contact page.


Comments


private detectives-portugal
bottom of page